paternalism

Paternalism is a summary term for ethical stance that a person’s autonomy is justifiably restricted to prevent self-harm, or to promote that person’s own well-being. It is grounded in the principle of beneficence.

As a "liberty-limiting" approach, paternalism is usually grounded in a theory of impairment: namely, that an individual lacks sufficient facts or mental capacity to make a sound choice. It is sometimes defended by a theory of future consent: viz., that the person whose liberty is circumscribed will (or, at least in principle, could) eventually agree that the restriction was desirable, given better facts or improved cognitive capacity in future.

Rationales for the limitation of individual human liberties generally divide into those relating to the individual whose liberty is circumscribed (like paternalism) versus those that relate to others, such as:

  • the harm principle - to prevent harm to others;
  • the offense principle - to prevent offense to others;
  • legal moralism - to prevent immoral acts (which acts can be viewed as harming either the individual, society or both).

See also:

 
 

   © 2002-2006 Contributing authors and University of Miami School of Medicine