HIPS Series > Privacy Issues for Students and Instructors > Quiz + Answers

The questions, answers and explanations are provided below. If you disagree with our answer, or have additional questions, please send email to pdpp@miami.edu. Include the text of the quiz question(s) with which you disagree in your correspondence.

•  •  •  •  •

1. Are HIPAA's legal-regulatory requirements for students different from those for regular members of the health care workforce?

A. Yes, students are subject to a lower standard of preformance, because they are in training.

B. No, students must meet the same standards as a regular member of the workforce performing the same tasks.

C. Maybe. It depends on whether the student is in an undergraduate or graduate program.

D. Maybe. It depends on whether the student is actually participating in treatment provision for patients.

B is correct. Care facilities may choose to set higher standards than the legal-regulatory minimum, but are not required to do so. Information access is what counts; the type of training program or responsibilities in it don't figure in the HIPAA requirement.

•  •  •  •  •

2. What about the ethical standards for student uses and disclosures of health information?

A. It's lower. Students deserve some slack. It's understood that students do not yet have full professional competencies.

B. It's obviously the same.

C. Some would say it's higher, because patients don't always benefit from students' access to their data, but the language of the regulation makes it the same.

D. It depends. Each health care facility can set its own standards.

B or C is correct. B meets the terms of the regulations, and is ethically sufficient for many. C is correct if you believe patients "donating" their information for training purposes deserve a higher standard.

•  •  •  •  •

3. Do patients have to provide extra authorization for training uses and disclosures of their information?

A. No. At least not because of HIPAA.

B. Yes. HIPAA requires this.

C. Only if the care setting is not formally designated as a training facility.

D. Only if training is not mentioned in the Notice of Privacy Practices.

A is correct. Training must be mentioned in the Notice of Privacy Practices, regardless of whether the facility is "officially" a training institution.

•  •  •  •  •

4. What about reporting privacy or security problems? Are the requirements for students the same as for regular workers?

A. Yes. Like any other member of the workforce, students are obligated to report problems they are not in a position to correct..

B. No. It's assumed that students are always supervised, and supervisors have the responsibility to report problems

A is correct. We thought you deserved an easy one.

•  •  •  •  •

5. Which of the following is generally a false statement about student-instructor relations?

A. Students’ position in the organizational hierarchy may put them in a better position to discover privacy problems, but in a less comfortable position to report what is found.

B. Instructors are under a particular burden to set a good example for their students, because they lead by example.

C. Instructors are under a particular burden to engender a climate where reporting of problems is expected and encouraged.

D. All of these are true.

D is the right choice here.

•  •  •  •  •

More information

 
 

   © 2002-2006 Contributing authors and University of Miami School of Medicine